I'm not sure if there's much of an audience here for music reviews, but this one called out to me. Each new album by Canadian prog trio
Rush has been a big event in my life since 1984's
Grace Under Pressure. Clockwork Angels is their first studio album in about 5 years, and I'm still mulling a lot over after just one listen to it all the way through. Still, I thought it worthwhile to get my thoughts down on virtual paper...
For the spoiler conscious (to the degree a rock album can have spoilers!) I'll put my comments on the lyrics and "story" below a cut at the bottom.
Before getting into the music, I must mention their use of alchemical symbols on the album cover. They've always catered to their geeky fans with stuff like this, but this goes above and beyond! Each of the 12 songs gets a unique symbol whose alchemical meaning resonates somehow with the lyrics. The full set corresponds to the clock-face in the image above, too. (Notice that the time on the clock is 9:12? If that's PM, then it's
21:12!) I was happy to see a few that I was considering for my
April A-Z posts on symbols, so, yeah, I'm the target audience, here. In the liner notes, it gets even more geekily complicated, with a nested inner ring of 8 symbols surrounding an even smaller ring of 4 symbols (the four elements, I think), surrounding a central core that's divided into two halves (day/sun and night/moon). We'll be analyzing that quite a bit, I think!
The band has been lauded for getting back to its prog-rock "concept album" roots with
Clockwork Angels, but I'm not sure how much that extends to the actual music. They do some stretching by bringing in some guest instrumentalists (strings and piano) as well as a BIT of flirtation with the synthesizers of old (e.g., some almost psychedelic sound effects on the title track). But, overall, I'd say that 80% to 90% of the music is straight guitar, bass, and drums, and the style wouldn't be a surprise to people familiar with their last two studio albums.
The composition and execution of the music is technically flawless (as far as this non-musician can tell). For dudes who will soon be celebrating their 60th birthdays, they're still in top form. However, there's one thing that prevents me from truly lavishing complete praise on the music. I think many people may recognize that you can split up Rush albums into two distinct time periods:
- Phase One (1974 to approx 1991): The era in which they knew how to write good, singable melodies.
- Phase Two (1991 to present): Um, not so much.
I'm using 1991 as a stand-in for the time period running from
Presto (1989) to
Counterparts (1993), during which the melodies seemed to gradually fade away. Does anyone else see this? To me, it's a major seismic fault running through their career. For some reason, the recent songs are plagued by lyrics that (though the ideas and poetry are brilliant) aren't just that suited to be melodic lyrics at all. It almost seems like there are too many syllables in each "line" for Geddy to sing. The end result is that he can't do anything other than just modulate up and down, up and down, by little half-steps of pitch, without the melody actually
going anywhere. Certainly makes it hard to have a memorable
hook to sing in the shower! :-)
But, for me, the music is secondary. It's really about the mind of this guy:
 |
| Professor Pratt Narpet |
and please click down past the cut to hear more about what words and ideas come pouring out of that mind...